Wednesday, January 05, 2005

A Comprehensive Theory of Religious Cognition

Since my post on children's God concepts seems to have sparked some interest, I've decided to write a few more posts on religion from a cognitive scientific perspective. The cognitive science and neuroscience of religion have become hot areas of research over the last several years, so there's a wealth of theory and data to draw on. So, if you're interested in work on religion from a cognitive perspective, expect two or three posts in the near future. A common theme that runs through the recent cognitive literature is that, contrary to the way scientists and philosophers have traditionally viewed religion, its cognitive aspects may actually be fairly mundane. As Justin Barrett writes1:
Are god-concepts much different from gorilla-concepts? Is performing a religious ritual a profoundly different action from sending a greeting card to a friend? Perhaps not. When considering the kind of cognitive resources required for representing and acquiring these concepts and actions, the sacred and the profane may be less discriminable than is commonly assumed... Much as language is naturally acquired as a result of cognitive preparedness plus exposure to a typical sociolinguistic environment, ordinary cognition plus exposure to an ordinary environment goes a long way towards explaining religion. (p. 29)
In this post, I want to focus on one particular theoretical framework for understanding religious cognition, as described in Scott Atran's In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion and Atran and Norenzayan's "Religion's evolutionary landscape: Counterintuition, commitment, compassion, communion" (A&N). Most of the quotes will be taken from the latter, because, well, it's online, so I can cut and paste them. In subsequent posts, I'll focus more on the cognitive and neuroscientific research.

It's important to remember that Atran and other psychologists, anthropologists, and neuroscientists who are studying religious cognition are studying ordinary religious beliefs and concepts, and not the complex concepts that you might find in formal presentations of the theologies of various religions. The latter are carefully worked out and studied, and may differ in many ways from everyday religious concepts. For example, theological reprsentations of God may present Him as existing outside of time, whereas everyday God concepts may treat him as experiencing time in ways similar to humans2). While theological concepts of God will have to utilize ordinary cognitive mechanisms, their representational and logical differences may result in the utilization of different mechanisms, or the same mechanisms in different ways. The theoretical and empirical resesarch on religious cognition is not designed to explore the cognitive foundations of theological concepts. Therefore, application of the research I will describe to theological problems would be a mistake. Furthermore, the research I will describe says nothing about the truth or falsity of any set of religious beliefs.

As the title of Atran's book and paper suggest, he and his colleagues approach religion from an evolutionary perspective3. Their primary insight is that religion is "a converging by-product of several cognitive and emotional mechanisms that evolved for mundane adaptive tasks" (A&N, p. 4). They use this insight, along with our knowledge of these "mundance mechanisms" from research on nonreligious cognition to explain four universal properties of religion:
1. Widespread counterfactual and counterintuitive beliefs in supernatural agents (gods, ghosts, goblins, etc.)
2. Hard-to-fake public expressions of costly material commitments to supernatural
agents, that is, offering and sacrifice (offerings of goods, property, time, life)
3. Mastering by supernatural agents of people’s existential anxieties (death, deception, disease, catastrophe, pain, loneliness, injustice, want, loss)
4. Ritualized, rhythmic sensory coordination of (1), (2), and (3), that is, communion
(congregation, intimate fellowship, etc.) (A&N, p. 3).
With respect to (1), the belief in"supernatural agents," many psychologists believe that humans have a "hair-triggered" agency-detection mechanism. This seems to develop in the first year of life, and though it tends to be very overextended in early life (children attribute agency to things like stuffed animals), even adults tend to extend agency to inanimate objects under uncertainty. Thus, A&N write:
From an evolutionary perspective, it’s better to be safe than sorry regarding the detection of agency under conditions of uncertainty. This cognitive proclivity would favor emergence of malevolent deities in all cultures, just as the countervailing Darwinian propensity to attach to protective caregivers would favor the apparition of benevolent deities. (p. 22)
To illustrate this, they give the following example from Lipkind4:
The earth and underworld are inhabited by supernaturals. . . . There are two kinds. Many are amiable and beautiful beings who have friendly relations with humans. . . . The others are ugly and dangerous monsters who cannot be placated. Their woods are avoided and nobody fishes in their pools. (p. 249)
Many religious rituals take advantage of this "hair-triggered" tendency to perceive agency by creating conditions in which agency will be attributed, such as the use of masks, or the detection of religious figures in inanimate objects (e.g., the Catholics who flocked to the Nashville coffee shop that I frequented in high school, because a pastry that resembled Mother Theresa had been discovered there). These intentional and uninentional recreations of the circumstances under which agency is usually detected can serve several purposes. A&N write:
Such manipulations can serve cultural ends far removed from the ancestral adaptive tasks that originally gave rise to those cognitive and emotional faculties triggered, although manipulations for religion often centrally involve the collective engagement of existential desires (e.g., wanting security) and anxieties (e.g., fearing death). (p.24)
In addition to activating ordinary agency concepts, supernatural agents and the worlds in which they exist also create counterintuitive or counterfactual conditions. Humans appear to have an "intuitive ontology," that contains the ordinary, factual entity-types that we encounter on a regular basis, such as persons, animals, and artifacts. We have certain beliefs about the nature and behavior of these different intuitive ontological categories, and supernatural agents are often designed in such a way that they violate these intuitive beliefs in important, but minimal ways. For instance, most ordinary God concepts contain both counterfintuitive information (e.g., omnipotence) and intuitive information associated with persons (e.g., emotions such as jealousy or anger). The counterintuitive aspects of supernatural agent concepts cause them to command attention, while the connection to established person concepts makes them easier to remember and transmit.

A third important property of supernatural agents is that they tend to be "emotionally powerful." Thus strong, vengeful, dangerous, and powerful God-concepts are common throughout the world's religions. Their ability to activate strong emotions makes them both more salient and more memorable. This property also facilitates the transmission of religious stories.

Atran describes his evolutionary explantion of (2), the existence of "costly" and "hard-to-fake" rituals and expressions of belief, by reference to the need for unequivocal and costly displays of commitment due to the potential for deception in human communities. A&N write:
[T]he human metarepresentational ability to deceive and defect has been managed by communicative displays of passionate commitment to omniscient supernatural agents, who unlike humans do not succumb to false beliefs and thus can act as guarantors for future in-group cooperation. Expression of religious prescriptions performatively signals and establishes cognitive and emotional commitment to seek convergence, but it doesn’t specify (the propositional content of) what people should converge to. The truth about religious prescriptions is accepted on faith and communicated through ritual display, not discovered or described as a set of factual or logical propositions. The result of such convergence is to perpetuate a stable community of cooperators who sacrifice for the group in the short run, but benefit from it in the long run.
By making displays of commitment costly and difficult to fake, community members ensure that those who perform those displays are genuinely committed. In turn, individuals who perform such displays are more likely to become more committed, because of the cost of performance. These rituals generally use mundane communicative techniques, but in strictly prescribed ways that are unquestinable in their veracity and appropriateness. Thus, rituals serve both as communicative displays of commitment and as instructions/reminders of what it is proper to believe.

The explanations of (1) and (2) serve as the foundation for the explanation of (3), the activation of existential anxieties by religious beliefs. Atran posits that the activation of existential anxieties, in general, triggers our tendency to detect agency. Thus, religious stories that activate such anxieties, and particularly those that involve supernatural agents who have control over the sorts of events that activate those anxieties (e.g., death, illness, or natural disaster) will be more salient and memorable. In addition, terror management theory5 argues that activating existential anxieties will lead to strengthened activation of one's own cultural or religious world view, which is designed to alleviate such anxieties, particularly those related to death. In turn, such anxieties will lead to increased animosity toward alternative world views. Thus, the activation of existential anxieties in religious settings also serves to strengthen communal ties, the function of religion highlighted in (2).

Finally, the properties of religious rituals highlighted in (4) also serve to increase the communal involvement of believers. By synchronizing the movements and regulating the sensory environment during the performance of religious rituals, religions are able to create a wealth of common experiences that serve to both strengthen community ties as well as communicating and strengthening the belief in religious truth. These rituals tend to incorporate all the aspects of religious concepts described in the explanations of (1)-(3), namely the activation of emotionally powerful, minimally counterintuitive concepts through the performance of costly and hard-to-fake acts of commitment.

This constitutes the basics of Atran's theory of religion. Obviously, I've just touched on most aspects of the theory, and there's much more to it. If the information here has piqued your interest, I recommend Atran's book, which is a fairly good read, and full of very interesting anecdotes and descriptions of non-European religious practices. He also describes some of the research that I'll be discussing in the next few posts, and gives a much more detailed evolutionary story, if that's your cup of tea.

1 Barrett, J.L. (2000). Exploring the natural foundations of religion. Trends in Cognitive Science, 4(1), 29-34.
2 Barrett, J.L. (In Press). Theological correctness: cognitive constraint and the study of religion. Method and Theory in the Study of Religion.
3 As I said in a recent post, I don't find evolutionary stories very interesting when it comes to cognition. They may be somewhat more interesting in anthropology, Atran's primary discipline, but for the most part, I could do without the evolutionary components of his theory.
4 Lipkind, W. (1940) Carajá cosmography. The Journal of American Folk-Lore, 53, 248–251.
5 Rosenblatt, A., Greenberg, J., Solomon, S., Pyszcynski, T., & Lyon, D. (1989). Evidence for terror management theory: I. The effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who violate or uphold cultural values. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57(4), 681-690. See also Lieberman, J. D. (2004). Terror management theory. American Journal of Psychiatry, 161, 1508.


Stewart Guthrie said...

Chris, nice review of the issue. I'd like to point out,though, that the source of the argument that religion stems from our tendency to detect more agents than are present, and the better-safe-than-sorry explanation of this tendency, is primarily Stewart Guthrie's 1980 "A cognitive theory of religion" (Current Anthropology vol. 21) and his 1993 Faces in the Clouds: A New Theory of Religion (OUP). Barret, whom you cite, gives the appropriate credit in his 2000 "Exploring the natural foundations of religion".
Regards, Stewart (

Anonymous said...

If I were gold für wow a boy again,world of warcraft gold I would practice perseverance wow gold cheap more often,maple meso and never give up a thing because it was or inconvenient. If we want light,Maple Story Account we must conquer darkness. Perseverance can sometimes equal genius in its gold kaufen “There are only two creatures,”cheap maplestory mesos syas a proverb, “who can surmount the pyramids—the eagle and the snail.” If I were a boy again,wow geld I would school myself into a habit of attention;maple mesos I would let nothing come between me and the subject in hand.maple story power leveling I would remember that a good skater never tries to skate in two directions at once.billig wow gold The habit of attention becomes part of our life, if we begain early enough. I often hear grown up people say maple story items“ I could not fix my attention on the sermon or book, although I wished to do so” , wow powerlevelingand the reason is, the habit was not formed in youth. If I were to live my life over again,wow leveling I would pay more attention to the cultivation of the memory. I would strengthen that faculty by every possible means,wow power leveling and on every possible occasion.maplestory powerleveling It takes a little hard work at first to remember things accurately;cheap archlord gold but memory soon helps itself, and gives very little trouble. It only needs early cultivation to become a power.

Anonymous said...

nike tnEnter the necessary language
translation, up to 200 bytes winter, moves frequently in Chinanike chaussures showing that the deep strategy of the Chinese market. Harvard Business School, tn chaussures according to the relevant survey data show that in recent years the Chinese market three brands, Adidas, mens clothingpolo shirts Li Ning market share at 21 percent, respectively, 20%, 17%. The brand is first-line to three lines of urban competition for mutual penetration. Side of theworld,announced layoffs, while China's large-scale facilities fists. The sporting goods giant Nike's every move in the winter will be fully s strategy. Years later, the Nike, Inc. announced the world's Fan

Anonymous said...

cheap polos
polo shirts
ralph lauren polo shirtssport shoes
ugg boots
puma shoes
chaussures pumamp4
trade chinalacoste polo shirts
chaussure puma femmewedding dressestennis racket
cheap handbags

Anonymous said...

MENSCLOTHING mans clothing
cheap ugg boots
converse shoes
wedding dresses
wholesale polo shirts
brand clothingcheap clothing
clothes sportspolos shirtair shoesair shoesed hardy clothinged hardy clothing

Anonymous said...

cheap hair straighteners
chi hair straightener
chi flat iron

new polo shirts
cheap Lacoste polo shirts
cheap Lacoste polo shirts

cheap handbags
cheap bags
puma chaussures
chaussures puma
chaussure puma

Men's North Face
Women's North Face

hair straighteners
sexy lingerie store
cheap ugg boots
tattoo wholesale
men's clothing
women's clothing

2009 nike shoes
new nike shoes
Women's max
Men's max 93
nike shox
Nike air force
Nike air max 2003
nike air max ltd
nike air max tn
Nike air rift
Nike air Yeezy
nike airmax
Nike air max 90
Nike air max 97
nike birds nest shoes
nike dunk
nike RT1 shoes
nike SB
nike shox shoes
Nike shox OZ shoes
Nike shox R2 shoes
Nike shox R3 shoes
Nike shox R4 shoes
Nike shox R5 shoes
Nike shox TL3
nike trainers lovers

tennis rackets
Wilson tennis rackets
HEAD tennis rackets
Babolat tennis rackets

Anonymous said...

China Wholesalers has been described as the world’s factory. buy products wholesaleThis phenomenom is typified by the rise ofbusiness. Incredible range of products available with China Wholesale “Low Price and High Quality” not only reaches directly to their target clients worldwide but also ensures that wholesale from china from China means margins you cannot find elsewhere and China Wholesale will skyroket your profits.china wholesale productsbuy china wholesalewholesale chinawholesale productsbuy products

Anonymous said...

We offer designer , custom wedding dress, cheap cell phonescheap wedding dressesbridal gowns, wedding gowns, Flower Girl Dresses andwholesale cell phonesso on. Buy tailor-made anddesigner wedding dresses designer to be a special brides now!

Anonymous said...

I would like to be the supporter of yours. Thank you for sharing such a nice article.
chaussures puma
puma speed cat
Nike Tn Chaussures
requin tn
nike shox
puma shoes
puma CAT
puma basket
puma speed
baskets puma
puma sport
puma femmes
puma shox r4 torch
nike air max requin
nike shox r3
shox rival r3
tn plus
chaussures shox
nike shox r4 torch
air max tn requin
nike tn femme
pas cher nike
tn chaussures
nike rift
nike shox nz
chaussures shox
nike shox rival
shox rival
chaussures requin
jeans online
cheap armani jeans
cheap G-star jeans

Anonymous said...

Your article is very good.I like it very much.
Once upon a time, there was a mouse father.He wanted to marry his daughter to the greatest person in the world.But, who was the greatest person in the world?Oh!
puma ferrari shoes
cheap nike shoesThe sun! He must be the greatest person in the world.The mouse father went to talk to the sun."Hello! Mr. Sun.
puma shoes
ferrari shoes
I know you are the greatest person in the world.Would you marry my daughter?""What? I'm not the greatest person in the world. The greatest person is the cloud.If he comes out, I’ll be covered."
nike shox nz
Ugg Boots
The mouse father went to talk to the cloud. “Hello! Mr. Cloud. I know you are the greatest person in the world. Would you marry my daughter?”
nike 360 air max
nike shox shoes
“What? I’m not the greatest person in the world. The greatest person is the wind.If he comes out, I’ll be blown away.”
cheap puma shoes
puma drift cat
The mouse father went to talk to the wind. “Hello! Mr. Wind. I know you are the greatest person in the world.Would you marry my daughter?” “What? I’m not the greatest person in the world. The greatest person is the wall. If he comes out, I’ll be stopped.”
cheap nike shox
nike air max 360
The mouse father went to talk to the wall. “Hello! Mr. Wall. I know you are the greatest person in the world. Would you marry my daughter?” “What? I’m not the greatest person in the world. The greatest person is YOU, the mouse.” “The greatest person in the world is … mouse?” “Yes, the greatest person in the world is mouse. See? If mouse comes out, I’ll be bit!”
nike air max
pumas shoes
The mouse father was very happy. He finally knew mouse was the greatest person in the world. He would marry his daughter to the handsome mouse next door.
cheap jeans
cheap levis jeans
ed hardy jeans

Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

新年快樂 said...


Anonymous said...

herve leger
herve leger dresses

chanel iman
chanel outlet
chanel handbag
Chanel Wallet
Chanel Watch
chanel purse

Chanel Sunglasses
chanel bags
chanel earrings
chanel jewelry
chanel shoes

Anonymous said...

cheap ghd
ghd straighteners
Benefit GHD
GHD IV Salon Styler
GHD Precious gift
Gold GHD
Kiss GHD
New pink GHD
Pink GHD
Pure Black GHD
Pure White GHD
Purple GHD
Rare GHD
polo boots
polo shoes
cheap straighteners
ghd hair straighteners
hair straighteners
Purple GHD IV Styler
Pure White GHD
Pure Black GHD
Pink GHD IV Styler
Kiss GHD Styler
Gray GHD IV Styler
Gold GHD IV Styler
GHD Rare Styler
GHD IV Salon Styler
Black GHD IV Styler
Benefit GHD IV Styler

my blog said...

i want to show you the following products:
gucci boots
gucci shoes
gucci t-shirt
gucci bags
gucci handbags
gucci clothing
gucci watch
gucci sunglasses
gucci jewelry
gucci boots
gucci shoes
gucci t-shirt
gucci bags
gucci handbags
gucci clothing
gucci watch
gucci sunglasses
gucci jewelry
gucci boots
gucci shoes
gucci t-shirt
gucci bags
gucci handbags
gucci clothing
gucci watch
gucci sunglasses
gucci jewelry

Hanthan said...

Armani Sunglasses
Burberry Sunglasses
Cartier Sunglasses
Chanel Sunglasses
Coach Sunglasses
D&G Sunglasses
Dior Sunglasses
ED Hardy Sunglasses
Fendi Sunglasses
LV Sunglasses
Oakley Sunglasses
Police Sunglasses
Ray Ban Sunglasses
Roberto Cavalli Sunglasses
Versace Sunglasses
cheap gucci sunglasses
cheap prada sunglasses
cheap D&G sunglasses
discount gucci sunglasses
discount prada sunglasses
discotunt D&G sunglasses
cheap oaklay sunglasses
discount oaklay sunglasses
sunglasses outlet
air max,Nike air max
air max 90
nike air max 90
air max 1
air max 95
nike air max 360
nike air max ltd
air max ltd
air max 360
air max classic,Air Max Huarache

Hanthan said...

air max light
air max bw
air max plus
air max 180
air max nike
air max TN
air max 87
air max 2010
air max outlet
timberland boots
timberland shoes
cheap timberland boots
timberland uk
timberland 2010
timberland outlet
Coach new bags
Chanel new bags
D&G new bags
Burberry new bags
Prada new bags
ED Hardy new bags
CHOLE new bags
Fendi new bags
Dooney&Bourke new bags
Juicy new bags
LV new bags
Gucci new bags