Wednesday, June 22, 2005

The Epistemology of Neuroimagining

Via the Online Papers in Philosophy blog, I discovered a nice paper by William Bechtel titled, "The Epistemology of Evidence in Cognitive Neuroscience." In the paper, he discusses in some detail, and with great examples, the ways in which neuroscientists have used three different methodologies: lesion/deficit studies, single-cell recordings, and neuroimagining (PET and fMRI in particular). The first two methods have been used for decades in neuroscience proper, and with a great deal of success. Single-cell recording studies, for instance, have painted an incredibly thorough picture of the visual cortex, especially its early parts (and most especially V1, about which we probably know more than we do about any other brain area). Still, both lesion and single-cell recording methods have their limits (it's unlikely that either will tell us much about higher-level cognitive processes anytime soon), and this has led cognitive neuroscientists to rely heavily on neuroimagining techniques. In my last post, I made some pretty snide remarks about neuroimagining studies (heck, the whole post was a snide remark about neuroimagining studies). I thought it might be appropriate, then, to link to a paper which does a good job of discussing the problems with neuroimagining techniques, and in particular, the problems with the subtraction method that is most commonly used in cognitive neuroscience.

If that's not enough for you, you might also check out Sartori and Umilta's excellent paper on the subtraction method, and alternative methods, titled, "How to Avoid the Fallacies of Cognitive Subtraction in Brain Imaging." It was published in Brain and Language in 2001 (vol. 74, pp. 191-212), but I can't seem to find an online version that doesn't require a subscription. If anyone knows of one, please let me know.

And finally, while you're reading Bechtel, you might also check out his very interesting paper on the symbolic-connectionist debate, which was also linked on the Online Papers in Philosophy blog. That paper is here.

7 comments:

business process management consultant said...

You may have not intended to do so, but I think you have managed to express the state of mind that a lot of people are in. The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where, is something a lot of us are going through. Please come visit my site business process management softwareswhen you got time.

fleet management consultant said...

This is just another reason why I like your website. I like your style of writing you tell your stories without out sending us to 5 other sites to complete the story. Please come visit my site automotive fleet management when you got time.

Getting Divorced said...

I really liked your blog! Please come visit my site Divorce Advice give me any valuable feedbacks

Document Shredding said...

Can you provide more information on this? I am new to the subject. Feel free to check out my site Document Shredding when you got time.

Unknown said...

Your post about Neuroimagining is excellent. I also read the papers of Sartori and Umilta, they were also good as you said.

Website SEO

Unknown said...

North dakota insurance agencies and brokers. North dakota car insurance, home owner insurance, health insurance, life insurance and more.

North dakota
Accident & Health Insurance
, North dakota
Aircraft & Aviation Insurance
, North dakota
Auto Insurance
, North dakota
Bail Bonds Referral Services
, North dakota
Boat & Yacht Insurance
, North dakota
Business Insurance
, North dakota
Business Interruption Insurance
, North dakota
Casualty insurance
, North dakota
Churches Insurance
, North dakota
Contents insurance
, North dakota
Corporate Insurance Adjusters
, North dakota
Credit Insurance
, North dakota
Crime insurance
, North dakota
Dental Insurance

Unknown said...

North dakota insurance companies, insurance agents brokers and insurance guide. Comprehensive information about North dakota car insurance, home owner insurance, health insurance, life insurance and more.

North dakota
Disability Insurance
, North dakota
Earthquake insurance
, North dakota
Estate Planning Insurance And Legal Services
, North dakota
Farm, Crop, & Livestock Insurance
, North dakota
Financial Guaranty & Life Insurance
, North dakota
Fire Insurance
, North dakota
Fleet Insurance
, North dakota
Flood Insurance
, North dakota
Foreign Insurance
, North dakota
Franchising
, North dakota
Government Insurance Carriers
, North dakota
Group Insurance
, North dakota
Health Insurance